Nosara vs Santa Teresa: An Honest Comparison for Property Buyers in 2026
Nosara and Santa Teresa are both surf towns on the Pacific side of the Nicoya Peninsula, but they sit in different provinces and follow different rules. Choose Nosara for a smaller, lower-density market where height and coverage limits are written down for every lot near the Ostional turtle refuge, as long as you can live with, or work around, the water freeze on the main beach aqueduct. Choose Santa Teresa for the bigger restaurant and rental market and daily scheduled flights into the Cóbano airport, as long as you're willing to check zoning, concessions and water lot by lot. On the latest data, the average Nosara short-term rental earned more over the last 12 months. Santa Teresa has nearly eight times as many active MLS listings: 201 against 26. We sell on the Santa Teresa side and have no Nosara listings, so the Nosara figures below are third-party data, each dated in the sources list.
Nosara vs Santa Teresa at a glance
| Nosara | Santa Teresa | |
|---|---|---|
| Province and municipality | Guanacaste; Nosara district of Nicoya canton (Municipality of Nicoya) | Puntarenas; Cóbano district (Concejo Municipal de Distrito de Cóbano) |
| MLS active listings, 15 Oct–15 Nov 2026 | 26, average asking price $1,353,486 (the set includes Coyote, San Juanillo and Marbella) | 201, average asking price $1,556,051, $4,421 per m² |
| Short-term rentals, 12 months to Oct 2026 (AirROI) | 924 listings; 41.1% occupancy; ~$452 per booked night; ~$45,500 average annual revenue | Cóbano district as a whole: 1,530 listings; 38.1% occupancy; ~$305 per night; ~$33,700 a year |
| New water connections | Playa Nosara aqueduct: AyA found no technical feasibility for new services (March 2024) and recommended no new availability letters | Depends on the local ASADA; ask for the letter in writing |
| Building rules near the coast | Ostional refuge buffer: 9 m height in the first km and on slopes visible from the beach, 12 m further in, 50% lot coverage, turtle-safe lighting | Sector zoning plans, Santa Teresa's dating from 1999–2000 |
| Scheduled flights | Sansa, San José to the Nosara airstrip, about 45 minutes | Cóbano airport (opened August 2023); Green Airways, six round trips a day |

The rocky, palm-backed shore typical of Mal País and the south end of the Santa Teresa strip, a different beach from Nosara’s long open sand at Guiones. Photo: en.danshiray.com
How do asking prices compare?
On the same MLS window, Santa Teresa had 201 active listings at an average asking price of $1,556,051, or $4,421 per square metre, against 26 in Nosara at $1,353,486. The Nosara set includes estates and land in Coyote, San Juanillo and Marbella, some of them very large, so it isn't a clean town figure. These are asking prices, not sales; Costa Rica publishes no sale prices by town. For the shape of the Santa Teresa market (the luxury tail, the inventory, and what to check on a listing), see our Santa Teresa market guide. Most of our own listings on that side are in Mal País: 4 listings at a median asking price of $650,000 (16 Nov 2026).

A close view of an empty Pacific beach, with forest coming down to the sand. A generated illustration, not a photograph of a named beach.
What do short-term rentals earn in each?
AirROI publishes figures for the 12 months to October 2026 (updated 5 November 2026). It shows them in colones, converted from US dollars at ₡461 per dollar, its typical rate for that period, so the dollar figures below use the same rate:
- Nosara: 924 active listings and 41.1% occupancy. The average booked night was about $452 (₡208,387), and average gross revenue per listing about $45,500 (₡20,970,379). March earns about 3.7 times as much as September, the weakest month.
- Cóbano district (Santa Teresa, Mal País, Montezuma and the villages around them; AirROI doesn't split out Santa Teresa): 1,530 active listings and 38.1% occupancy. The average booked night was about $305 (₡140,425), and revenue per listing about $33,700 (₡15,531,061). January earns about three times September.
These are averages across very different homes. In Nosara, 75% of listings have a pool, and those with one earned about 3.8 times as much as those without. Neither figure is a yield: Nosara's higher nightly rate comes with a high entry price. Our Vacation Rental ROI guide works out what an average Cóbano listing nets after management, platform fees, 13% VAT and rental-income tax. Santa Teresa's rental market, including what to model on a listing, is also covered in the market guide.
Can you get a water letter to build?
In Nosara's main beach area, possibly not from the public system. In March 2024, AyA, the national water utility, studied the Playa Nosara aqueduct. It served 1,191 connections and about 4,023 people. Demand was 44.02 litres a second against production of 35.15. AyA concluded that the aqueduct lacked the technical feasibility to take on new services and recommended issuing no more availability letters (memo GSD-UEN-GAR-2024-01121, 19 March 2024). As of 17 November 2026 we found no later AyA decision lifting it. Get the provider's current position in writing before you buy.
A building permit needs proof of water: a letter from AyA or the ASADA, or a permitted well or concession from MINAE (INVU construction regulation, article 117). If a Nosara lot is sold "with water", ask which source it is and see the permit.
Santa Teresa has the same rule in a different form. Each letter comes from the ASADA that serves that part of town, so ask for it in writing, for the specific lot. In both towns, a titled lot with a registered meter or a current water letter is worth more than the same lot without one.
What can you build, and where?
Nosara. The Municipality of Nicoya's construction regulation for the Ostional refuge buffer zone has been in force since its publication in La Gaceta on 28 February 2020. It applies within 5 km of the refuge's boundary:
- Height: new buildings are capped at 9 metres in the direct-impact area, which is the first kilometre plus the slopes that face the sea and can be seen from the beach. Further in, the cap is 12 metres (article 6).
- Coverage: no more than 50% of a lot can be built on (article 5).
- Lighting: outdoor lights must be shielded, low-wattage (50 W incandescent or under 8 W LED), red, orange or yellow, and not shine onto the beach (article 7).
- Wastewater and glass: every project needs wastewater treatment, and glass must be protected against bird collisions.
The regulation says it applies until Nicoya's zoning plan comes into force.
Santa Teresa. The coastal strip is governed by sector zoning plans, each covering one stretch of beach. Santa Teresa's plan was approved in January 1999 and published in La Gaceta on 19 April 1999, and its regulation was signed in January 2000. The Cóbano council's zoning-plan page lists separate plans for Santa Teresa, Playa Carmen, Mal País, Montezuma–Cabuya, Tambor and the other sectors of the district. Find out which plan, and which zone within it, covers the lot. Our Santa Teresa market guide has the detail, and our neighborhoods guide is the street-by-street picture.
How does the Maritime Zone apply?
The same way in both towns, because it's national law. Under Law 6043, the first 200 metres from the ordinary high-tide line is the Maritime Zone. The first 50 metres are public, and the next 150 can only be held as a municipal concession. Concessions are barred to foreigners with less than five years' residence and to companies more than 50% foreign-owned (article 47). What differs between the towns is how much titled land sits behind the beach and which zoning plan, if any, covers the concession. Our beachfront guide explains how to tell titled land from a concession on a listing.
How do you get there?
Flights. Sansa flies San José to Nosara in about 45 minutes. Santa Teresa's scheduled flights land at the Cóbano airport, inaugurated on 5 August 2023, where Green Airways runs six round trips a day. Check both schedules for your dates.
Roads. According to the Presidency, the 10 km of Route 160 between Garza and Nosara, which runs past Guiones and Pelada, was paved by January 2021. The same announcement says the 33 km between Paquera and Cóbano, on the Santa Teresa side, were rehabilitated as well. Side roads and hill roads in both towns are mostly unpaved, so drive them in the rainy season before you commit.

A dry-season river crossing on the Santa Teresa coast, January 2023. Photo: Jeffrey Eisen / Pexels

Surfboards leaning by a dirt road in a small Costa Rican surf town. A generated illustration, not a photograph of a named street.
Is Santa Teresa in Guanacaste?
No. Santa Teresa, Mal País, Montezuma, Cabuya and Tambor are in the Cóbano district of Puntarenas province, on the southern tip of the Nicoya Peninsula. Nosara and Sámara are in Guanacaste. The difference is practical, not just geography: different local governments issue the permits, collect the property tax and approve the zoning plans. In Santa Teresa that is the Concejo Municipal de Distrito de Cóbano; in Nosara, the Municipality of Nicoya.
Nosara or Santa Teresa: which should you buy in?
The data doesn't pick a winner, but it does sort buyers:
- Nosara fits buyers who want a lower-density town with written height and coverage limits, and who are buying a finished house that already has a water connection, or land with a permitted private source.
- Santa Teresa fits buyers who want the larger rental and restaurant market and are prepared to check which zoning plan a property sits in and whether its ASADA will issue a letter. If Santa Teresa is over budget, look at the Mal País side, or across the peninsula at Montezuma, where our median asking price was $550,000 on 16 November 2026.
In both towns, see the registry record, the water letter or well permit, and the access before you sign.

Mal País beach at dusk. Photographed in March 2018.
Frequently asked questions
Is Nosara more expensive than Santa Teresa?
On the regional MLS for 15 October to 15 November 2026, Nosara's 26 active listings averaged $1,353,486 and Santa Teresa's 201 averaged $1,556,051. The Nosara set includes large estates outside town, so neither average is a like-for-like price.
Which earns more as a vacation rental, Nosara or Santa Teresa?
Over the 12 months to October 2026, the average Nosara listing grossed about $45,500 at 41.1% occupancy. The Cóbano district, which includes Santa Teresa, averaged about $33,700 at 38.1% (AirROI, at its own rate of ₡461 per dollar). Nosara's entry prices are also high, so compare yields, not revenue.
Can I get a water letter to build in Nosara?
Often not from the public system near the beach. In March 2024, AyA found the Playa Nosara aqueduct had no technical feasibility for new services and recommended no new availability letters. Get the provider's current position in writing, and ask for the permit if a lot claims its own well.
How tall can I build in Nosara?
Within 5 km of the Ostional refuge, the limit is 9 metres in the first kilometre and on sea-facing slopes visible from the beach, and 12 metres further inland. Lot coverage can't exceed 50%. That's the Municipality of Nicoya's buffer-zone regulation, in force since February 2020.
Is Santa Teresa in Guanacaste?
No. Santa Teresa is in the Cóbano district of Puntarenas province. Nosara is in Guanacaste.
Where these facts come from
Checked on 17 November 2026.
- Cover photo: Playa Guiones, Nosara, from a light aircraft, by Alegutierrezc, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons; resized and converted to WebP.
- Asking prices: 2 Costa Rica Real Estate MLS market insights, 15 Oct–15 Nov 2026: Nosara and Santa Teresa.
- Rentals: AirROI, 12 months to Oct 2026, updated 5 Nov 2026: Nosara and Cóbano. Dollar figures use AirROI's own conversion rate, ₡461 per US$.
- Water: AyA memo GSD-UEN-GAR-2024-01121, 19 Mar 2024 (hosted by Voz de Guanacaste); INVU Reglamento de Construcciones, art. 117.
- Ostional buffer zone: Municipality of Nicoya regulation, La Gaceta 40, 28 Feb 2020.
- Santa Teresa zoning: Santa Teresa zoning plan; Cóbano council, zoning plans.
- Maritime Zone: Law 6043, arts. 9, 10 and 47.
- Flights: Sansa, Nosara; Cóbano airport.
- Roads: Presidencia de la República, 20 Jan 2021.
- Our listings: our listings for sale as of 16 Nov 2026: Mal País 4, median $650,000; Montezuma 45, median $550,000.
Ready to Find Your Dream Property?
Explore our curated selection of properties in Costa Rica's beautiful Nicoya Peninsula.
Explore Properties